Attorneys and Parties

Respondents/Defendants-Appellants: Town of Islip and other unnamed respondents/defendants
Attorneys: Judson K. Siebert, Robert C. Zitt

Petitioner/Plaintiff-Respondent: Suffolk Regional Off-Track Betting Corporation
Attorneys: Cara P. Cronin, Sean M. Cronin

Brief Summary

Issue

Whether property owned by a regional off-track betting corporation, including a hotel, dining facilities, and vacant parcels, qualifies for exemption under Racing, Pari-Mutuel Wagering and Breeding Law § 513(1) [exempts regional off-track betting corporations’ money and property from taxation, but subjects portions of real property used for purposes unrelated to their corporate purpose to real property taxes].

Lower Court Held

All 11 parcels owned by Suffolk Regional Off-Track Betting Corporation (SROTB) were fully exempt from Town of Islip real property taxes.

Disposition

The appellate court reversed the exemption for the 10 vacant and undeveloped parcels but upheld the full exemption for the parcel containing Jake’s 58 Hotel & Casino.

Why

SROTB demonstrated that the hotel and dining facilities supported its betting operations and revenue, but it failed to establish that the vacant parcels were used for its corporate purpose.

Background

SROTB is a public benefit corporation whose corporate purpose is to generate government revenue through an off-track betting system and curb illegal wagering. In May 2021, it acquired 11 parcels in the Village of Islandia and Town of Islip. One parcel contained Jake’s 58 Hotel & Casino; the remaining 10 were vacant and undeveloped. Because the betting and gaming area occupied approximately 25% of the building, the Town’s assessor granted only a 25% exemption for the developed parcel. In January 2024, SROTB commenced a hybrid proceeding under Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR) article 78 [provides a procedure for judicial review of governmental action, including mandamus to compel performance of a legal duty] and a declaratory judgment action seeking full exemption for its property.

Lower Court Decision

The Supreme Court, Suffolk County, directed that the petition be granted in an order dated July 8, 2024. Its July 22, 2024 judgment granted the petition and declared all 11 parcels fully exempt from Town real property taxes.

Appellate Division Reversal

The appellate court modified the judgment by denying the petition and dismissing the proceeding as to the 10 vacant parcels, deleting the declaration that those parcels were exempt, and remitting the matter for an amended judgment declaring them nonexempt. It affirmed the full exemption for the developed parcel. SROTB’s evidence showed that its hotel and dining facilities operated at a loss to increase betting revenue and that betting revenue would decline significantly without them; the Town failed to raise a triable factual issue. By contrast, a transcript excerpt concerning conditional site-plan approval, which was outside the record, was inadequate to establish qualifying use of the vacant parcels. The separate appeal from the intermediate order was dismissed, and the issues were reviewed on the appeal from the judgment.

Legal Significance

The taxpayer bears the burden of establishing entitlement to a tax exemption. Under Racing, Pari-Mutuel Wagering and Breeding Law § 513(1), facilities supporting betting operations may qualify even when they are not themselves gaming areas, provided their use is related to the corporation’s statutory purpose. Ownership alone did not establish entitlement to exemption for the vacant parcels. The court also explained that a challenge to denial of a mandatory exemption concerns the taxing authority’s jurisdiction over the property, so judicial review is not limited to evidence presented to that authority.

🔑 Key Takeaway

A regional off-track betting corporation may obtain a full exemption for a parcel containing hotel and dining facilities that support its betting operations, but it must separately establish a qualifying corporate use for vacant parcels.