Categories

Attorneys and Parties

Deshaun Felton
Appellant
Attorneys: Patricia Pazner, Samantha Jerabek

The People
Respondent
Attorneys: Eric Gonzalez, Julian Joiris, Leonard Joblove, Hannah Thomas

Brief Summary

Issue

Criminal law issue concerning the duration of a sentencing order of protection and whether it properly credited the defendant for jail time already served.

Lower Court Held

The Supreme Court, Kings County, accepted the defendant's guilty plea to attempted murder in the second degree, imposed sentence, and issued an order of protection that was to remain in effect until and including January 1, 2042.

Disposition

The Appellate Division vacated only the portion of the order of protection that set its expiration date through January 1, 2042, remitted for a new determination of the proper duration, and otherwise affirmed the judgment of conviction.

Why

The order of protection failed to credit the defendant for jail time served. The defendant's claim was reviewable despite no objection because the sentencing court did not announce the duration of the order of protection at the plea or sentencing proceedings, leaving him no practical opportunity to object, and the People did not dispute the error.

Background

Deshaun Felton pleaded guilty in Supreme Court, Kings County, to attempted murder in the second degree. At sentencing, the court imposed sentence and issued an order of protection. On appeal, Felton challenged the duration of that order, arguing that it did not account for the jail time he had already served.

Lower Court Decision

The lower court rendered judgment on January 2, 2024, convicting Felton upon his guilty plea and imposing sentence. It also issued an order of protection that remained in effect until and including January 1, 2042.

Appellate Division Reversal

The Appellate Division held that preservation did not bar review because the duration of the order of protection was not announced at either the plea or sentencing proceedings. It vacated the portion of the order of protection setting the expiration date at January 1, 2042, remitted the matter to Supreme Court, Kings County, for a new determination of the duration consistent with credit for jail time served, and directed that the order remain in effect pending that determination. The judgment of conviction was otherwise affirmed.

Legal Significance

This decision reinforces that an appellate court may review an unpreserved challenge to the duration of an order of protection when the defendant had no practical opportunity to object in the trial court. It also confirms that sentencing courts must properly account for jail time served when calculating the expiration date of a criminal order of protection.

🔑 Key Takeaway

A defendant may obtain appellate relief from an incorrectly dated order of protection even without a contemporaneous objection when the duration was never announced in court, and the proper remedy is vacatur of the expiration date and remittal for recalculation, not reversal of the conviction.