The People of the State of New York v Gregory Duplessis
Categories
Attorneys and Parties
Brief Summary
Criminal law; whether the prosecution's peremptory strike of a prospective juror was racially discriminatory under the Batson jury-selection framework.
County Court denied the defendant's Batson challenge, allowed the peremptory strike to stand, and entered judgment on the jury's verdict convicting defendant of two counts of criminal sale of a controlled substance in the third degree and two counts of criminal possession of a controlled substance in the third degree.
The Appellate Division reversed the judgment of conviction and remitted the matter for a new trial.
The trial court's step-three Batson finding was unsupported by the record. The prosecutor's stated race-neutral reason that juror No. 95 had 'broken English' and struggled to communicate was contradicted during voir dire by both defense counsel and the court, the prosecutor asked the juror no follow-up questions, and on remittal the court made no meaningful credibility findings and relied largely on transcripts and a substitute prosecutor with no firsthand knowledge.
Background
Defendant was tried in Schenectady County on narcotics charges and, in March 2023, a jury found him guilty of two counts of criminal sale of a controlled substance in the third degree and two counts of criminal possession of a controlled substance in the third degree. During jury selection, the trial prosecutor used peremptory challenges against prospective jurors of color, prompting a Batson objection by the defense. As to juror No. 95, the prosecutor said the juror had 'broken English' and struggled to communicate. Defense counsel and County Court both stated at the time that they did not share that view. County Court nevertheless denied the Batson objection without completing step three of the Batson analysis. On an earlier appeal, the Appellate Division withheld decision and remitted for a determination on pretext. On remittal, County Court stated it had no independent recollection of the voir dire and relied on transcripts, personal notes, and counsel's arguments before again denying the Batson challenge.
Lower Court Decision
County Court sentenced defendant to concurrent prison terms of three years, followed by three years of postrelease supervision, and rejected his Batson challenge. After remittal from the Appellate Division, County Court again denied the Batson claim, finding no objective evidence that the prosecutor's reason was racially motivated and no similarly situated jurors treated differently.
Appellate Division Reversal
The Appellate Division held that County Court's step-three Batson determination could not stand. The record showed that, unlike another prospective juror whom the court itself said was difficult to understand, neither the court nor defense counsel had any trouble understanding juror No. 95. The prosecutor asked juror No. 95 no questions that might have supported the stated concern. On remittal, County Court did not meaningfully explain its notes, had no independent memory of the voir dire, and heard from a different prosecutor who relied only on the transcript. Because the ruling rested on a credibility determination not supported by the record or recalled observations, the judgment was reversed and the case was remitted for a new trial.
Legal Significance
The decision underscores that Batson step three turns on credibility and discriminatory intent, and trial courts must create a meaningful record when a peremptory strike is justified by a juror's alleged speech or communication difficulties. When the stated race-neutral reason involves traits such as accent, fluency, tone, or manner of speaking, those matters may not appear on a transcript, making contemporaneous findings and credibility assessments essential. Without such a record, deference to the trial court is not warranted.
A prosecutor's claim that a juror was hard to understand cannot support a peremptory strike where the record does not back it up, the court made no real step-three credibility finding, and the juror's alleged communication problem is otherwise contradicted by the voir dire record.
