Hector Robles v Fordham Valentine Associates LLC et al.; Fordham Valentine Associates LLC et al. v East End Concrete Industries, Inc. and Top Notch Finishes, Inc.
Attorneys and Parties
Brief Summary
Construction accident litigation involving whether a subcontractor had to provide contractual indemnification under a broad carpentry trade agreement, and whether contribution and common-law indemnification claims were barred by the Workers' Compensation Law [limits contribution and common-law indemnification claims against an employer when the injured worker received workers' compensation benefits unless the worker suffered a statutorily defined grave injury].
The Supreme Court, Bronx County denied Top Notch Finishes, Inc.'s motion for summary judgment insofar as it sought dismissal of the contractual indemnification claim asserted by the third-party plaintiffs and the cross-claim asserted by East End Concrete Industries, Inc. for contribution and common-law indemnification.
The Appellate Division modified the order only to dismiss East End Concrete Industries, Inc.'s cross-claim as abandoned; otherwise, it affirmed the denial of summary judgment on the contractual indemnification claim.
Top Notch did not make a prima facie showing that plaintiff's injury did not arise out of its carpentry work, because plaintiff was injured while moving sheetrock used in that work under his foreman's direction and pursuant to Top Notch's contractual duty to move its own materials. East End's cross-claim was not defended on appeal and, in any event, was barred because plaintiff received workers' compensation benefits and did not suffer a grave injury within the meaning of the Workers' Compensation Law.
Background
Plaintiff Hector Robles was injured on a construction project while moving sheetrock boards from the first floor to the basement. The sheetrock was used in Top Notch Finishes, Inc.'s carpentry work, and plaintiff was performing the task under his foreman's instructions. Top Notch's trade agreement required it to move its own materials as needed on the site. The owner- and contractor-related third-party plaintiffs sought contractual indemnification from Top Notch under a clause requiring Top Notch to indemnify them for claims arising out of or resulting from the carpentry trade work performed by or through Top Notch. East End Concrete Industries, Inc. also asserted a cross-claim for contribution and common-law indemnification.
Lower Court Decision
The Supreme Court, Bronx County denied Top Notch's summary judgment motion to the extent it sought dismissal of the third-party plaintiffs' contractual indemnification claim and East End's cross-claim for contribution and common-law indemnification.
Appellate Division Reversal
The Appellate Division modified the order to grant Top Notch summary judgment dismissing East End's cross-claim as abandoned, and otherwise affirmed. It held that Top Notch failed to eliminate factual issues as to whether plaintiff's injuries arose out of its carpentry trade work, so dismissal of the contractual indemnification claim was not warranted. The court also noted that East End's claim would be barred under the Workers' Compensation Law because plaintiff received workers' compensation benefits and his injuries were not grave injuries.
Legal Significance
The decision reinforces that a broadly worded contractual indemnification clause using the phrase "arising out of" may apply where the injured worker was handling materials integral to the subcontractor's trade work and doing so pursuant to the subcontractor's contractual obligations. It also confirms that contribution and common-law indemnification claims against an employer are unavailable where the worker received workers' compensation benefits and did not sustain a grave injury under the Workers' Compensation Law.
A subcontractor cannot defeat a contractual indemnification claim on summary judgment where the accident has a plausible connection to its assigned trade work, especially when the worker was moving that subcontractor's materials under the trade contract. Separate contribution and common-law indemnification claims against the employer will fail absent a statutory grave injury.
