Attorneys and Parties

Plaintiff-Appellant: Fareverse, LLC
Attorneys: Joseph F. Battista

Defendant-Respondent: Deborah D. Bourne
Attorneys: Lorna A. McGregor

Brief Summary

Issue

Mortgage foreclosure and the equitable authority to toll interest accruing on a mortgage loan.

Lower Court Held

The Supreme Court, Westchester County, granted the borrower's request to toll the accrual of interest on the mortgage loan.

Disposition

The portion of the December 12, 2024 order granting interest tolling was reversed, with costs, and that branch of the borrower's motion was denied.

Why

The borrower failed to demonstrate that the plaintiff was responsible for unexplained delays or other wrongful conduct in the foreclosure action.

Background

In March 2022, Fareverse, LLC commenced an action against Deborah D. Bourne and other defendants to foreclose a mortgage encumbering real property in Mount Vernon. Bourne answered the complaint and moved, among other things, to toll the accrual of interest on the mortgage loan. Fareverse opposed the motion.

Lower Court Decision

By order dated December 12, 2024, the Supreme Court, Westchester County, with Justice Doris M. Gonzalez presiding, granted the branch of Bourne's motion seeking to toll interest. Fareverse appealed that portion of the order.

Appellate Division Reversal

The Appellate Division unanimously reversed the order insofar as appealed from, on the law, with costs, and denied the request to toll interest. Although courts have broad equitable discretion over interest in foreclosure actions, Bourne did not demonstrate unexplained delays attributable to Fareverse or other wrongful conduct warranting tolling.

Legal Significance

The decision reaffirms that foreclosure actions invoke a court's equitable powers and that interest determinations depend on the particular facts, including wrongful conduct by either party. Unexplained delays in prosecuting a foreclosure action may justify tolling or cancellation of interest, but equitable relief requires a supporting factual showing.

🔑 Key Takeaway

A borrower seeking to toll mortgage interest must establish facts supporting equitable relief; the borrower's failure to demonstrate unexplained delay or wrongful conduct by the plaintiff required denial of tolling here.