Shapiro v Kushnick-Carr
Categories
Attorneys and Parties
Brief Summary
A defamation and anti-Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation (SLAPP) dispute arising from a negative Google review about an attorney's law practice.
The Supreme Court, Nassau County, denied the defendant's motion to dismiss the amended complaint and denied her request for attorneys' fees and costs.
The Appellate Division reversed and granted dismissal of the amended complaint and granted the defendant entitlement to attorneys' fees and costs, remitting for calculation of the amount.
The court held the Google review was speech in a public forum on an issue of public interest under Civil Rights Law § 76-a[1][a][1], [2] [defining a SLAPP suit as an action based on communications in a public forum or other lawful speech on an issue of public interest], shifting the burden to the plaintiff under CPLR 3211(g) [on a motion to dismiss in a SLAPP case, once defendant shows the action involves public petition and participation, plaintiff must demonstrate the claims have a substantial basis in law]. The plaintiff failed to show a substantial basis in law because the review was nonactionable pure opinion rather than a provably false statement of fact.
Background
The plaintiff, attorney Akiva Shapiro, sued defendant Sheryl Kushnick-Carr for defamation and related relief based on a Google review posted on his law firm's public business profile. The review stated: "Don's Not Use Him!! He is what gives bad names to attorneys. A Tinker of many types of law A MASTER OF NONE!" The amended complaint sought at least $500,000 in damages and removal of the review. The defendant moved to dismiss under CPLR 3211(a) [rule allowing pre-answer dismissal] and sought attorneys' fees under Civil Rights Law § 70-a(1)(a) [authorizing attorneys' fees and costs to a defendant upon a showing that the action lacked a substantial basis in fact and law and could not be supported by a substantial argument for changing existing law], arguing the suit was a SLAPP action.
Lower Court Decision
The Supreme Court, Nassau County, denied the branches of the defendant's motion seeking dismissal of the amended complaint and an award of attorneys' fees and costs.
Appellate Division Reversal
The Appellate Division held that the defendant met her initial burden of showing the case involved public petition and participation because the statements were posted on Google, a public forum, and concerned the professional competence of a licensed attorney serving the public, which was not a purely private matter under Civil Rights Law § 76-a(1)(d) [providing that "public interest" is construed broadly to mean any subject other than a purely private matter]. The burden therefore shifted to the plaintiff to show the defamation claim had a substantial basis in law. He failed to do so because the review's language was vague, figurative, hyperbolic, and contextually recognizable as opinion on a consumer review platform. The phrases "what gives bad names to attorneys" and "a tinker of many types of law, a master of none" lacked precise, provably true-or-false meaning and did not imply undisclosed defamatory facts. The court therefore dismissed the amended complaint and awarded the defendant attorneys' fees and costs, remitting for a determination of amount.
Legal Significance
The decision reinforces New York's broadened anti-SLAPP protections for online consumer commentary. Public online reviews of professionals may qualify as speech on matters of public interest, and once that threshold is met, plaintiffs must demonstrate a substantial legal basis for their claims. The case also underscores that strongly worded criticism, rhetorical hyperbole, and idiomatic insults on review platforms are often treated as nonactionable pure opinion rather than defamatory fact.
A negative Google review criticizing an attorney's competence was protected as pure opinion in a public forum on a matter of public interest, so the defamation suit was dismissed as a SLAPP action and the reviewer was entitled to attorneys' fees.
