Categories

Attorneys and Parties

The People of the State of New York
Respondent
Attorneys: Alvin L. Bragg, Jr., Faith DiTrolio

Armand Calisha
Defendant-Appellant
Attorneys: Twyla Carter, Alyssa Gamliel

Brief Summary

Issue

Criminal law sentencing; whether the sentence imposed after a guilty plea to attempted robbery in the second degree was excessive.

Lower Court Held

The trial court convicted defendant upon her guilty plea of attempted robbery in the second degree and sentenced her to six months in jail followed by five years' probation.

Disposition

The Appellate Division vacated the six-month jail term but otherwise affirmed the judgment, including the conviction and probationary sentence.

Why

The appellate court found the sentence excessive to the extent of the incarceration term and modified the judgment as a matter of discretion in the interest of justice.

Background

Defendant Armand Calisha pleaded guilty in Supreme Court, New York County, to attempted robbery in the second degree. The court then imposed a sentence of six months in jail to be followed by five years of probation.

Lower Court Decision

Supreme Court, New York County, rendered judgment on September 5, 2023, convicting defendant on her guilty plea and sentencing her to six months' incarceration plus five years' probation.

Appellate Division Reversal

The Appellate Division, First Department, unanimously modified the judgment in the interest of justice by vacating the six-month prison term, and otherwise affirmed.

Legal Significance

The decision reflects the Appellate Division's discretionary authority to reduce or modify a criminal sentence when it concludes that the punishment imposed is excessive, even where the conviction itself is upheld.

🔑 Key Takeaway

Calisha's conviction and probation remained intact, but the appellate court eliminated the jail component because it deemed that portion of the sentence excessive.