Categories

Attorneys and Parties

Defendant-Appellant: Raquan Reed
Attorneys: Twyla Carter, Hilary Dowling

Prosecution-Respondent: The People of the State of New York
Attorneys: Eric Gonzalez, Leonard Joblove, Ann Bordley

Brief Summary

Issue

Criminal procedure: the validity of prosecution by a superior court information (SCI) after a grand jury has already returned an indictment covering the same criminal transaction.

Lower Court Held

The Supreme Court, Kings County, accepted Reed's guilty plea to attempted robbery in the first degree under the SCI and imposed sentence.

Disposition

The appellate court reversed the November 18, 2022 judgment, vacated the guilty plea, and dismissed the SCI.

Why

Reed waived indictment and consented to prosecution by SCI only after a grand jury had returned an indictment covering the same criminal transaction, rendering the SCI a nullity.

Background

A felony complaint and a subsequent indictment charged Reed with attempted assault in the first degree, attempted assault in the second degree, and criminal facilitation in the fourth degree. As part of a negotiated disposition, Reed later waived indictment and consented to prosecution under an SCI charging attempted robbery in the first degree. He pleaded guilty to that charge and was sentenced. He also separately pleaded guilty to criminal facilitation in the fourth degree in full satisfaction of the indictment.

Lower Court Decision

On November 18, 2022, the Supreme Court, Kings County, with Justice Vincent M. Del Giudice presiding, entered judgment convicting Reed of attempted robbery in the first degree upon his guilty plea under the SCI and imposed sentence.

Appellate Division Reversal

The appellate court unanimously reversed the judgment on the law, vacated Reed's guilty plea, and dismissed the SCI as jurisdictionally defective. The prosecution conceded the defect. The court reviewed the claim despite Reed's failure to raise it below, his guilty plea, and his unchallenged waiver of the right to appeal. It did not remit for further proceedings because Reed had separately been convicted of criminal facilitation in full satisfaction of the indictment, and the prosecution did not request remittal. The court did not reach Reed's alternative ground for challenging the SCI.

Legal Significance

A waiver of indictment and consent to prosecution by SCI are invalid when made after a grand jury has returned an indictment covering the same criminal transaction. A challenge to this jurisdictional defect does not require preservation and survives both a guilty plea and a waiver of the right to appeal.

🔑 Key Takeaway

A negotiated guilty plea cannot cure a jurisdictionally invalid SCI filed after an indictment covering the same criminal transaction; the resulting conviction must be reversed, the plea vacated, and the SCI dismissed.