M.P. v William Cosby, Jr., et al.
Attorneys and Parties
Brief Summary
Entertainment industry employer liability for alleged sexual assaults by a celebrity employee under negligent hiring, retention, and supervision principles.
The trial court denied The Carsey-Werner Company, LLC's (CW) motion to dismiss the negligent hiring, retention, and supervision claim.
The Appellate Division reversed that denial and dismissed the complaint against CW.
The majority held that, even assuming CW knew of Bill Cosby's alleged propensities, the complaint did not plead a sufficient nexus between CW's employment of Cosby and plaintiff's injuries. Plaintiff's single visit to the studio, where no assault or other independently tortious conduct allegedly occurred, and Cosby's use of his status as the star of The Cosby Show to impress plaintiff were not enough to show that CW's premises, property, or resources were used to commit the alleged assaults.
Background
Plaintiff alleged that she first met Bill Cosby in about 1987 after he invited her to the set of The Cosby Show, which was produced and controlled by CW. According to the complaint, Cosby told her that the show wanted to hire her to appear and possibly sing on a special episode. Plaintiff further alleged that, on multiple occasions between 1987 and 1990, Cosby gave her beverages that caused her to lose consciousness and then sexually assaulted her. She claimed CW negligently hired, retained, and supervised Cosby because it allegedly knew or should have known of his propensity to mistreat and sexually abuse women associated with or visiting the show.
Lower Court Decision
The Supreme Court, New York County, denied CW's motion to dismiss the negligent hiring, retention, and supervision claim, allowing that claim to proceed against CW.
Appellate Division Reversal
The Appellate Division, First Department, reversed and granted CW's motion to dismiss. Relying on Moore Charitable Found. v PJT Partners, Inc. and its own recent decision in B.B. v Cosby, the Court held that the complaint failed to allege that Cosby committed any tortious act on CW's premises or directly used CW's property or resources to carry out the assaults. The Court concluded that plaintiff's one studio visit and Cosby's use of his celebrity status and access to the set to gain her trust did not create the required causal nexus between CW's employment relationship with Cosby and the later assaults. Kennedy and Gesmer, JJ., dissented, with Justice Gesmer arguing that the studio visit and alleged promise of work on the show sufficiently connected CW's resources to Cosby's alleged grooming of plaintiff.
Legal Significance
The decision reinforces a narrow application of negligent hiring, retention, and supervision liability in New York when harm is caused by an employee outside the employer's premises. The majority emphasized that an employer's premises or resources must be tied to independently tortious or illegal conduct, not merely used to impress, groom, or lure a plaintiff. The ruling also treats B.B. v Cosby as controlling and limits the reach of Moore Charitable Found. v PJT Partners, Inc. and Waterbury v New York City Ballet, Inc. to cases where employer resources were used more directly in the wrongful act itself.
An employer will not face negligent hiring, retention, or supervision liability merely because an employee used workplace access, prestige, or a studio visit to gain a plaintiff's trust; the complaint must allege a stronger nexus showing that the employer's premises, property, or resources were actually used to commit or directly facilitate the tortious conduct.
