Attorneys and Parties

Mark A. Newgarden, et al.
Plaintiff-Appellant/Cross-Respondent
Attorneys: Brian J. Markowitz

Havemeyer Estates, LLC
Defendant-Respondent
Attorneys: David M. Peraino, Matthew C. Schwartz, Andrew J. Neiman

David Blumenkrantz
Defendant-Respondent/Cross-Appellant
Attorneys: David M. Peraino, Matthew C. Schwartz, Andrew J. Neiman

Brief Summary

Issue

Real estate and construction access-license dispute involving unpaid license fees, contractual legal fees, account stated claims, and whether a limited liability company member could be personally liable for company-related obligations.

Lower Court Held

The Supreme Court, Kings County, denied the plaintiffs summary judgment on liability for breach of contract as to unpaid license fees and legal fees and on the account stated claim, granted David Blumenkrantz summary judgment dismissing the fraud, negligence, gross negligence, and nuisance claims against him, and denied his request to dismiss the account stated claim against him.

Disposition

The Appellate Division reversed the denial of summary judgment to the plaintiffs on liability for breach of contract insofar as Havemeyer Estates, LLC failed to pay license fees after June 2020 and legal fees, and also reversed the denial of David Blumenkrantz's request for summary judgment dismissing the account stated claim against him.

Why

The record showed that Havemeyer Estates, LLC stopped paying during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) shutdown but did not resume payments after the shutdown ended, so any force majeure defense no longer excused nonpayment after June 2020. The account stated claim against Havemeyer failed on the plaintiffs' motion because Havemeyer had objected to the invoices in a June 17, 2020 email. David Blumenkrantz could not be held personally liable absent a basis to pierce the corporate veil under Limited Liability Company Law § 609(a) [members of limited liability companies are not personally liable for company debts, obligations, or liabilities whether arising in tort, contract, or otherwise], and the plaintiffs offered no such proof.

Background

Havemeyer Estates, LLC began construction on its property at 20 Havemeyer Street in Brooklyn in early 2019. To facilitate the work, it entered into an access agreement with plaintiff Mark A. Newgarden, the owner of the adjacent property at 18 Havemeyer Street. The agreement permitted access to Newgarden's property for construction-related work and required Havemeyer to pay license fees during the agreement term and additional amounts until the contemplated work was completed. The agreement also required Havemeyer to pay legal fees incurred as a result of breaches. The plaintiffs later sued, alleging that Havemeyer failed to pay license fees and legal fees and seeking recovery on an account stated against both Havemeyer and its member, David Blumenkrantz. The payment dispute centered in part on whether the agreement's force majeure clause excused nonpayment during the COVID-19 shutdown and after it ended.

Lower Court Decision

The lower court denied the plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment on liability for the breach of contract claim relating to unpaid license fees and legal fees and denied summary judgment on the account stated claim. It granted Blumenkrantz summary judgment dismissing the fraud, negligence, gross negligence, and nuisance claims against him, but denied his request to dismiss the account stated claim asserted against him personally.

Appellate Division Reversal

The Appellate Division modified the order. It held that the plaintiffs were entitled to summary judgment on liability for breach of contract insofar as Havemeyer failed to pay license fees after the COVID-19 shutdown ended in June 2020 and for contractual legal fees arising from that breach. It further held that Blumenkrantz was entitled to summary judgment dismissing the account stated claim against him personally because the obligation to pay arose from the access agreement with Havemeyer, and the plaintiffs failed to show any basis to pierce the corporate veil. The court otherwise affirmed, including the denial of the plaintiffs' motion on the account stated claim against Havemeyer because Havemeyer had timely objected to the invoices.

Legal Significance

The decision underscores that a force majeure defense tied to pandemic shutdown conditions does not indefinitely excuse payment obligations once the disabling event ends. It also reinforces that an account stated claim requires proof that invoices were retained without timely objection or were partially paid, and that an express objection can defeat summary judgment on that theory. Finally, it confirms the strong protection afforded to limited liability company members under Limited Liability Company Law § 609(a) [members of limited liability companies are not personally liable for company debts, obligations, or liabilities whether arising in tort, contract, or otherwise] absent evidence warranting veil piercing.

🔑 Key Takeaway

After a temporary shutdown ends, a contracting party must resume required payments unless the contract clearly provides otherwise, and a limited liability company member generally cannot be personally charged for the company's contract or account stated liability without concrete veil-piercing proof.