Attorneys and Parties

Wilmington Savings Fund Society
Plaintiff-Appellant
Attorneys: Robert W. Griswold

David Lopez, Jr.
Defendant-Respondent
Attorneys: Joseph A. Altman

Brief Summary

Issue

Residential mortgage foreclosure; whether a non-borrower heir and current property owner may assert a lender's noncompliance with Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL) 1304 [requires a lender to send a pre-foreclosure notice before commencing a home-loan foreclosure action] and a contractual default-notice condition precedent.

Lower Court Held

The lower court denied plaintiff's motion for summary judgment and an order of reference, leaving unresolved whether the statutory and contractual pre-foreclosure notices had been properly mailed.

Disposition

The Appellate Division reversed the denial of summary judgment and the order of reference and granted plaintiff's motion against David Lopez, Jr.

Why

After plaintiff discontinued the action against the borrower's estate and waived any deficiency claim, Lopez remained only as an heir and owner who took title subject to the mortgage. In that individual capacity, he was a stranger to the note and mortgage and therefore lacked standing to raise defenses based on alleged noncompliance with RPAPL 1304 or the contractual default-notice requirement.

Background

In 2008, defendant's father executed a note and mortgage for $458,000 in favor of Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., plaintiff's predecessor-in-interest. Wells Fargo allegedly mailed both an RPAPL 1304 [requires a lender to send a pre-foreclosure notice before commencing a home-loan foreclosure action] notice and a contractual pre-action default notice in late 2009, then commenced this foreclosure action in January 2010 seeking foreclosure, sale, and a deficiency judgment. The father died in 2014, and David Lopez, Jr. was appointed administrator of the estate. In 2015, the property was deeded to Lopez individually, and in 2016 the note and mortgage were assigned to plaintiff. In 2019, plaintiff obtained partial summary judgment on all issues except mailing of the statutory and contractual notices. In 2021, plaintiff renewed its motion, waived any deficiency against the estate, and discontinued the action against the estate, leaving Lopez only as the individual owner and heir.

Lower Court Decision

Supreme Court, Bronx County, denied plaintiff's motion for summary judgment and an order of reference to the extent appealed from, based on the remaining issue concerning compliance with the statutory and contractual notice requirements.

Appellate Division Reversal

The Appellate Division unanimously reversed, on the law, without costs, and granted plaintiff's motion for summary judgment and an order of reference as against David Lopez, Jr. The court held that once the estate was no longer a party, Lopez in his individual capacity lacked standing to assert the borrower's personal defenses based on alleged failure to mail the RPAPL 1304 notice or the contractual default notice.

Legal Significance

The decision confirms that in a mortgage foreclosure action, defenses based on noncompliance with RPAPL 1304 and analogous contractual default-notice provisions are personal to the original borrower or obligor on the note. A transferee, heir, or current owner who holds title subject to the mortgage, but is not a party to the note and mortgage instruments, generally cannot invoke those defenses once the borrower's estate is no longer in the case.

🔑 Key Takeaway

If a foreclosure action proceeds only against a non-borrower heir or transferee who owns the property subject to the mortgage, that party cannot defeat summary judgment by asserting notice defenses belonging solely to the original borrower.