Attorneys and Parties

Violet Rebecca Gathers
Respondent
Attorneys: Violet Rebecca Gathers

David Luton Gathers
Appellant
Attorneys: David Luton Gathers

Brief Summary

Issue

Family law issue involving upward modification of child support and proper calculation of a parent's income for basic child support purposes.

Lower Court Held

The Family Court denied the father's objections and left in place the amended Support Magistrate order directing him to pay $1,096 biweekly in basic child support based on income of $185,613.22.

Disposition

The Appellate Division reversed the Family Court's denial of the father's objections, vacated the portion of the amended order setting basic child support at $1,096 biweekly, and remitted for a new calculation.

Why

The Support Magistrate improperly used a January 2025 pay stub that included a one-time holiday payment and treated that payment as if it were recurring biweekly income. Under Family Court Act § 413[1][b][5][i] [requiring child support calculations to begin with the parent's gross income as should have been or should be reported on the most recent federal income tax return], and the cited case law, that nonrecurring payment should have been excluded.

Background

The parties are the parents of one child born in 2006. A 2017 order required the father to pay $324 biweekly in basic child support. In March 2022, the mother filed a petition seeking an upward modification under Family Court Act article 4. After a hearing, the Support Magistrate issued a June 4, 2025 order setting child support at $1,505 biweekly based on income of $252,166.34. The father objected, and the Family Court remanded for an explanation of the income calculation. In an amended order dated October 1, 2025, the Support Magistrate recalculated the father's income at $185,613.22 and set basic child support at $1,096 biweekly. The father again objected, arguing that a one-time holiday payment of $2,447.69 had been wrongly treated as recurring income.

Lower Court Decision

The Family Court, Kings County, denied the father's objections to the amended order and allowed the child support award of $1,096 biweekly to stand.

Appellate Division Reversal

The Appellate Division reversed insofar as appealed from, granted the father's objections to the portion of the amended order setting basic child support at $1,096 biweekly, vacated that portion of the amended order, and remitted the matter to the Family Court, Kings County, for a new calculation of the father's basic child support obligation. The court also directed that, in the interim, the father shall continue paying $1,096 biweekly.

Legal Significance

The decision reinforces that in child support proceedings, income calculations must be grounded in Family Court Act § 413[1][b][5][i] [requiring use of the parent's gross income as should have been or should be reported on the most recent federal income tax return], although a court may consider income for an incomplete tax year. It further confirms that one-time or nonrecurring payments should not be annualized and treated as regular income when calculating basic child support.

🔑 Key Takeaway

A Support Magistrate may look at current-year earnings, but a single nonrecurring payment, such as a one-time holiday payment, cannot be treated as recurring income when setting child support.