US Bank National Association v Vento
Categories
Attorneys and Parties
Brief Summary
Mortgage foreclosure procedure, specifically whether a referee's report could support a judgment of foreclosure and sale where the record did not support the referee's finding that the property should be sold in one parcel.
The Supreme Court, Queens County, confirmed the referee's report, granted the plaintiff's motion for a judgment of foreclosure and sale, and directed that the mortgaged property be sold.
The Appellate Division reversed the order and judgment of foreclosure and sale insofar as appealed from, denied the branches of the plaintiff's motion to confirm the referee's report and for a judgment of foreclosure and sale, rejected the portion of the referee's report stating that the property should be sold in one parcel, and remitted for further proceedings.
Although the defendant was not prejudiced by the referee's failure to give notice or hold a hearing, and the amount-due calculation was supported by admissible evidence, the referee did not identify any documents or other sources supporting the conclusion that the property should be sold in one parcel. That finding therefore lacked record support.
Background
In August 2009, the plaintiff began a mortgage foreclosure action against Jason Vento and others concerning real property in Queens. The Supreme Court granted the plaintiff's motion for an order of reference in May 2017 and later appointed a substitute referee in February 2024. The plaintiff then moved to confirm the referee's report and for a judgment of foreclosure and sale. Vento opposed the motion, arguing among other things that the referee had not provided notice or held a hearing and that the report was defective.
Lower Court Decision
The Supreme Court, Queens County, granted the plaintiff's motion to confirm the referee's report and for a judgment of foreclosure and sale, confirmed the report, and directed sale of the mortgaged premises.
Appellate Division Reversal
The Appellate Division held that the lack of notice or a hearing before the referee did not by itself require reversal because the defendant had an opportunity to challenge the report before the Supreme Court and therefore suffered no prejudice. The appellate court also held that the referee's computation of the amount due was supported by the record and not based on inadmissible evidence. However, it found that the referee's determination that the premises should be sold in one parcel was unsupported because the referee failed to identify any documents or other sources for that conclusion. On that basis, it reversed, denied confirmation of the report and the request for a foreclosure judgment, rejected that portion of the report, and remitted for a new determination on whether the premises can be sold in parcels.
Legal Significance
The decision reinforces two foreclosure principles: first, a referee's failure to hold a hearing is not automatically fatal absent prejudice to the opposing party; second, every material finding in a referee's report, including how the property should be sold, must be supported by the record. A trial court may not confirm unsupported referee findings simply because other portions of the report are proper.
In a foreclosure case, a referee's report may support the amount due yet still be rejected if a separate recommendation—such as selling the property in one parcel—lacks documentary or record support.
