Shulman
Stile v C-Air Customhouse Brokers-Forwards, Inc. March 30, 2026
Stile v C-Air Customhouse Brokers-Forwards, Inc. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided 2026-03-24 CategoriesCommercial / Business Litigation Judges Manzanet-Daniels, J.P.ShulmanRodriguezHiggittRosado Attorneys and Parties Clare Marie Stile Plaintiff-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Yvette J. Sutton C-Air Customhouse Brokers-Forwards, Inc., et al. Defendants-Respondents-Appellants Attorneys: John H. Chun Brief Summary Issue A dispute involving closely held customs brokerage and…
Philip Tower v Structure Tone, LLC March 30, 2026
Philip Tower v Structure Tone, LLC Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided 2026-03-24 CategoriesConstruction LawTort Actions / Personal Injury Judges Manzanet-DanielsShulmanRodriguezHiggittRosado Attorneys and Parties Jacobson & Company, Inc. Third-Party Defendant-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Evy Kazansky Philip Tower Plaintiff-Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Y. Albert Dauti TGA 730 Third Avenue Owner LLC Defendant-Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Lisa L. Gokhulsingh ABCO Peerless…
Sheryl R. Menkes v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., et al. March 30, 2026
Sheryl R. Menkes v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided 2026-03-24 CategoriesMedical Malpractice Judges Manzanet-DanielsShulmanRodriguezHiggittRosado Attorneys and Parties Sheryl R. Menkes Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Sheryl R. Menkes Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., et al. Defendants-Appellants Attorneys: Patrick Lawless Brief Summary Issue Medical malpractice; whether a plaintiff may…
Seaton v. Babad March 30, 2026
Seaton v. Babad Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided 2026-03-24 CategoriesReal Estate / PropertyCommercial / Business LitigationGeneral Civil Litigation Judges Manzanet-DanielsShulmanRodriguezHiggittRosado Attorneys and Parties EK Realty, LLC Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Robert W. Frommer Debra Seaton et al. Plaintiffs-Respondents Attorneys: Craig Saunders Chaim Babad et al. Defendants Brief Summary Issue Commercial property management and receivership…
William Grey v. LIC Development Owner, L.P. March 23, 2026
William Grey v. LIC Development Owner, L.P. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 17, 2026 Judges Manzanet-Daniels, J.P.KapnickShulmanHagler Attorneys and Parties William Grey Plaintiff-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Roger A. Sachar LIC Development Owner, L.P. Defendant-Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Matthew S. Brett Brief Summary Issue Rent-stabilized overcharge claims in a building receiving Real Property Tax Law (RPTL)…
People of the State of New York v. Jeremy Scott-Manson March 23, 2026
People of the State of New York v. Jeremy Scott-Manson Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 17, 2026 Judges Manzanet-DanielsKapnickShulmanChanHagler Attorneys and Parties People of the State of New York Respondent Attorneys: Alvin L. Bragg, Jr., Malancha Chanda Jeremy Scott-Manson Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Twyla Carter, Mary-Kathryn Smith Brief Summary Issue Criminal law—Sandoval impeachment,…
Ricardo Estrella v 20 Bruckner, LLC, et al. March 23, 2026
Ricardo Estrella v 20 Bruckner, LLC, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 17, 2026 Judges Manzanet-Daniels, J.P.KapnickShulmanChanHagler Attorneys and Parties Ricardo Estrella Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Michael J. Prisco 20 Bruckner, LLC; GDI Construction, LLC; Bruckner Ventures, LLC Defendants-Appellants Attorneys: John T. Hague Bruckner Associates LLC Defendant Brief Summary Issue New York…
Lenicio Robles v. 53-63 Walton LLC, et al. March 23, 2026
Lenicio Robles v. 53-63 Walton LLC, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 17, 2026 Judges Manzanet-Daniels, J.P.KapnickShulmanChanHagler Attorneys and Parties Lenicio Robles Plaintiff-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Anthony DeStefano 53-63 Walton LLC, et al. Defendants-Respondents-Appellants Attorneys: David M. Chaise Brief Summary Issue Construction site fall from an unsecured ladder; application of New York…
People of the State of New York v. A.Y. March 23, 2026
People of the State of New York v. A.Y. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 17, 2026 Judges Manzanet-Daniels, J.P.KapnickShulmanChanHagler Attorneys and Parties A.Y. Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Jenay Nurse Guilford, Luz Beato The People of the State of New York Respondent Attorneys: Darcel D. Clark, Jonathan L. Gold Brief Summary Issue Criminal procedure…
Eric Lackenbauer v. 162 Fifth Avenue Associates LLC et al.; Inscape (New York) Inc. et al. March 23, 2026
Eric Lackenbauer v. 162 Fifth Avenue Associates LLC et al.; Inscape (New York) Inc. et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 17, 2026 Judges Manzanet-Daniels, J.P.KapnickShulmanChanHagler Attorneys and Parties L&K Partners, Inc. Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Michael J. Kozoriz Eric Lackenbauer Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Jillian Rosen Brief Summary Issue Construction-site trip hazard liability under…