Scarpulla, J.P.
Deutsche Bank National Trust Company v Archie Washington et al. April 13, 2026
Deutsche Bank National Trust Company v Archie Washington et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided April 7, 2026 CategoriesMortgage ForeclosureReal Estate / Property Judges Scarpulla, J.P.Friedman, J.Shulman, J.Rodriguez, J.Rosado, J. Attorneys and Parties Deutsche Bank National Trust Company Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Michael S. Hanusek Archie Washington Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Tyler J. Hogan 3989 Paulding,…
Mahbub Azizy et al. v Hunts Point Terminal Produce Cooperative Association, Inc., et al. April 13, 2026
Mahbub Azizy et al. v Hunts Point Terminal Produce Cooperative Association, Inc., et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided April 7, 2026 CategoriesTort Actions / Personal Injury Judges Scarpulla, J.P.Friedman, J.Shulman, J.Rodriguez, J.Rosado, J. Attorneys and Parties Mahbub Azizy and Zarlast Azizy Plaintiffs-Appellants Attorneys: Christopher J. DelliCarpini Khalil Mohammad Plaintiff-Appellant Attorneys: Shawn…
In the Matter of Yuchen Lin, for the Judicial Dissolution of XS Franchise, L.L.C. v Xu Sun April 13, 2026
In the Matter of Yuchen Lin, for the Judicial Dissolution of XS Franchise, L.L.C. v Xu Sun Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided April 7, 2026 CategoriesCommercial / Business Litigation Judges Scarpulla, J.P.Friedman, J.Shulman, J.Rodriguez, J.Rosado, J. Attorneys and Parties Yuchen Lin Petitioner-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Ripal J. Gajjar Xu Sun Respondent-Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Thomas H.…
Molina v. Appula Management Corp.; Matias v. Picdale Realty LLC; Pizarro v. Appula Management Corp.; Genyard v. Picdale Realty LLC March 23, 2026
Molina v. Appula Management Corp.; Matias v. Picdale Realty LLC; Pizarro v. Appula Management Corp.; Genyard v. Picdale Realty LLC Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties Appula Management Corp. et al. Defendants-Appellants Attorneys: Robert J. Cosgrove Picdale Realty LLC et al. Defendants-Appellants Attorneys: Robert…
Lesly M. Villar Payano v. Abdulla Al Nahshal et al. March 23, 2026
Lesly M. Villar Payano v. Abdulla Al Nahshal et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties Lesly M. Villar Payano, etc. Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Anthony Destefano Abdulla Al Nahshal et al. Defendants-Appellants Attorneys: Richard E. Barber Brief Summary Issue Personal injury—motor vehicle versus pedestrian; summary…
People of the State of New York v. Erica U. March 23, 2026
People of the State of New York v. Erica U. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties Erica U. Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Twyla Carter, Mariel Stein People of the State of New York Respondent Brief Summary Issue Criminal law—sentencing surcharges and fees Lower Court Held The…
People of the State of New York v. Angelo Torres March 23, 2026
People of the State of New York v. Angelo Torres Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties People of the State of New York Respondent Attorneys: Darcel D. Clark, Lindsey Richards Angelo Torres Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Jenay Nurse Guilford, Alec D. Miran Brief Summary Issue Criminal…
Owen May v. Gerson Gibbs March 23, 2026
Owen May v. Gerson Gibbs Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties Gerson Gibbs Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Craig Riha Owen May Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Stephen R. Markeman Brief Summary Issue Securities industry arbitration before the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and a replevin claim over a brass…
In the Matter of J.A.W., and Others, Children Under Eighteen Years of Age March 23, 2026
In the Matter of J.A.W., and Others, Children Under Eighteen Years of Age Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties Mother (name withheld) Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Michael Weinstein Administration for Children's Services Petitioner-Respondent Attorneys: Muriel Goode-Trufant, Eva J. Jerome J.W. and J.A. Children Attorneys: Donna C.…
O’Flaherty v. Columbo March 23, 2026
O'Flaherty v. Columbo Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided March 19, 2026 Judges Scarpulla, J.P.KapnickPitt-BurkeMichaelHagler Attorneys and Parties Defendant-Appellant New Land Contracting Attorneys: C. Briggs Johnson Plaintiff-Respondent Brian O'Flaherty Defendants-Respondents Planet 550 Corp., et al. Defendants Joseph Columbo, et al. Brief Summary Issue Construction/worksite safety and employer liability for intentional torts by non-employees…