Moulton
Aurora Beauchamp et al. v New York City Transit Authority et al. September 22, 2026
Aurora Beauchamp et al. v New York City Transit Authority et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided September 17, 2026 CategoriesTort Actions / Personal Injury Judges MoultonMendezGesmerO'Neill LevyMichael Attorneys and Parties New York City Transit Authority, et al. Defendants-Appellants Attorneys: Jennifer B. Adler Aurora Beauchamp Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Edward T. Cooper Saul Beauchamp…
The People of the State of New York v. David Sheard July 20, 2026
The People of the State of New York v. David Sheard Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided July 16, 2026 CategoriesCriminal Law Judges MoultonScarpullaShulmanRodriguezMichael Attorneys and Parties The People of the State of New York Appellant Attorneys: Darcel D. Clark, Paul A. Andersen David Sheard Defendant-Respondent Attorneys: Caprice R. Jenerson, Rachel Lindy Brief…
6985 Trinity Centre LLC v City National Bank July 6, 2026
6985 Trinity Centre LLC v City National Bank Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided June 30, 2026 CategoriesGeneral Civil Litigation Judges Manzanet-DanielsMoultonShulmanRosadoO'Neill Levy Attorneys and Parties 6985 Trinity Centre LLC Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Mitchel H. Ochs City National Bank Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Ingrid Tatiana Medina Rodriguez Brief Summary Issue Judgment enforcement and banking law, specifically…
Junior Carty Acosta v. 22-12 Jackson Owner LLC, et al. July 6, 2026
Junior Carty Acosta v. 22-12 Jackson Owner LLC, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided June 30, 2026 CategoriesConstruction LawEmployment / LaborTort Actions / Personal Injury Judges Manzanet-DanielsMoultonShulmanRosadoO'Neill Levy Attorneys and Parties Junior Carty Acosta Plaintiff-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Bill Cafaro Feldman Lumber-US LBM, LLC Defendant-Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Angelika Arias-Linares 22-12 Jackson Owner LLC; Britt…
Gleinin Martinez v. The Bronx County Historical Society July 6, 2026
Gleinin Martinez v. The Bronx County Historical Society Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided July 2, 2026 CategoriesEmployment / Labor Judges MoultonMendezGesmerO'Neill LevyMichael Attorneys and Parties Gleinin Martinez Plaintiff-Respondent-Appellant Attorneys: Russell E. Adler The Bronx County Historical Society Defendant-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Laurent S. Drogin Brief Summary Issue Employment and wage-and-hour dispute involving whether a…
Encarnacion v. St. Barnabas Hospital June 18, 2026
Encarnacion v. St. Barnabas Hospital Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided June 9, 2026 CategoriesTort Actions / Personal Injury Judges MoultonFriedmanPitt-BurkeRosadoMichael Attorneys and Parties Juana Encarnacion Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Jillian Rosen St. Barnabas Hospital Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Samantha E. Quinn Brief Summary Issue Personal injury and premises liability, focused on whether the jury should have…
Suazo v 501 Madison-Sutton LLC June 8, 2026
Suazo v 501 Madison-Sutton LLC Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided June 2, 2026 CategoriesConstruction LawTort Actions / Personal Injury Judges MoultonKapnickGonzálezShulmanChan Attorneys and Parties Superior Acoustics, Inc. Second Third-Party Defendant-Appellant; Third Third-Party Plaintiff-Appellant Attorneys: Jessica L. Smith 501 Madison-Sutton LLC Defendants-Respondents; Second Third-Party Plaintiffs-Respondents Attorneys: Ryan S. Ulrich Atlantic Interiors, Inc. Third…
Taylor v. The City of New York, et al. May 25, 2026
Taylor v. The City of New York, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided May 19, 2026 CategoriesCivil RightsEmployment / Labor Judges MoultonScarpullaKapnickShulmanMichael Attorneys and Parties Otis Taylor Plaintiff-Appellant Attorneys: Fred B. Lichtmacher The City of New York Defendant-Respondent Attorneys: Bo Malin-Mayor Sergeant Martin Toczek Defendant-Respondent Attorneys: Lalit K. Loomba Brief Summary…
Ellise Park v Stephen Butkow May 11, 2026
Ellise Park v Stephen Butkow Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided May 7, 2026 CategoriesFamily Law / Matrimonial Judges Moulton, J.P.Gesmer, J.Higgitt, J.Michael, J.Chan, J. Attorneys and Parties Ellise Park Plaintiff-Appellant Attorneys: Nina S. Gross Stephen Butkow Defendant-Respondent Attorneys: Karen B. Rosenthal Brief Summary Issue Matrimonial litigation involving an interim counsel fee award…
AIG Property Casualty Company as subrogee of Adam Schwartz v High Line Construction Group LLC, The Night LLC, et al. May 11, 2026
AIG Property Casualty Company as subrogee of Adam Schwartz v High Line Construction Group LLC, The Night LLC, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, First Department Date Decided May 7, 2026 CategoriesConstruction LawGeneral Civil Litigation Judges MoultonGesmerHiggittMichaelChan Attorneys and Parties Sammy's Interior Painting, Inc. Defendant-Appellant-Respondent Attorneys: Gerald F. Kirby High Line Construction Group LLC Defendant-Respondent-Appellant…