Montour, J.P.

The People of the State of New York v. Rhodesia Anderson Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided June 26, 2026 CategoriesCriminal Law Judges Montour, J.P.Ogden, J.Greenwood, J.Nowak, J.Hannah, J. Attorneys and Parties The People of the State of New York Plaintiff-Appellant Attorneys: Michael J. Keane, Michael J. Hillery Rhodesia Anderson Defendant-Respondent Attorneys: Nicholas…

Kathleen Gumkowski, as Administrator of the Estate of Gregory Gumkowski, deceased, and Kathleen Gumkowski, individually v. Thomas Schwaab, M.D., et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided December 23, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.SmithGreenwoodNowakKeane Attorneys and Parties Plaintiff-Respondent Kathleen Gumkowski, individually Plaintiff-Respondent Kathleen Gumkowski, as Administrator of the Estate of Gregory Gumkowski, deceased Attorneys:…

People v. Young Dissent Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided November 21, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.Smith, J.Greenwood, J.Nowak, J.Keane, J. Attorneys and Parties The People of the State of New York Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Sandra Doorley, Martin P. McCarthy, II James Young Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Julie Cianca, Piotr Banasiak Brief Summary Issue Criminal law—sexual offenses against…

M.H., an infant, by his mother and natural guardian, Shanique B., and Shanique B., individually v. Magdi E. Sayegh, M.D., Adel E. Chouchani, M.D., and Chouchani, Sayegh & Bagnarello, M.D., LLP, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided November 21, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.SmithGreenwoodNowakKeane Attorneys and Parties M.H., an infant, by his…

M.H., an infant, by his mother and natural guardian, Shanique B., and Shanique B., individually v. Magdi E. Sayegh, M.D., Adel E. Chouchani, M.D., and Chouchani, Sayegh & Bagnarello, M.D., LLP, et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided November 21, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.Smith, J.Greenwood, J.Nowak, J.Keane, J. Attorneys and Parties Plaintiffs-Respondents:…

The People of the State of New York v. James Young Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided November 21, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.Smith, J.Greenwood, J. (dissenting)Nowak, J. (dissenting)Keane, J. Attorneys and Parties The People of the State of New York Respondent Attorneys: Sandra Doorley, Martin P. McCarthy, II James Young Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Julie…

O. Gregory Zazulak v. Shirley Sarna, as Executor of the Estate of Elaine Sarna, deceased Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided November 21, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.SmithGreenwoodNowakKeane Attorneys and Parties O. Gregory Zazulak Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: O. Gregory Zazulak Shirley Sarna, as Executor of the Estate of Elaine Sarna Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Matthew A. Lenhard…

Matter of Waterfront Operations Associates LLC v New York State Department of Health Reversed Court Appellate Division, Fourth Department Date Decided November 21, 2025 Judges Montour, J.P.Smith, J.Nowak, J.Keane, J. Attorneys and Parties Petitioner-Appellant — Waterfront Operations Associates LLC d/b/a Ellicott Center for Rehabilitation and Healthcare Attorneys: Suzan Arden Respondents-Respondents — Barbara Guinn, as Commissioner…