McShan
In the Matter of Halle E. Price v New York State Board of Law Examiners July 20, 2026
In the Matter of Halle E. Price v New York State Board of Law Examiners Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided July 16, 2026 Categories Administrative LawGeneral Civil Litigation Judges Ceresia, J.Aarons, J.P.Pritzker, J.Fisher, J.McShan, J. Attorneys and Parties Halle E. Price Appellant Attorneys: Tyler Maulsby New York State Board of…
Matter of New York Civil Liberties Union v New York State Police June 29, 2026
Matter of New York Civil Liberties Union v New York State Police Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided June 25, 2026 CategoriesAdministrative LawCivil Rights Judges ClarkAaronsPritzkerMcShanRyba Attorneys and Parties New York Civil Liberties Union Respondent Attorneys: Peter Trombly New York State Police Appellant Attorneys: Beezly J. Kiernan Brief Summary Issue Public records access…
In the Matter of the Claim of Jennifer Croom v New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision et al. June 18, 2026
In the Matter of the Claim of Jennifer Croom v New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision et al. First_time Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided June 11, 2026 CategoriesEmployment / LaborAdministrative Law Judges ClarkAaronsPritzkerMcShanRyba Attorneys and Parties Appellant Jennifer Croom Attorneys: Mark C. Somers Respondent New York State Department of Corrections…
Matter of Todd A. Pletcher v New York State Gaming Commission March 16, 2026
Matter of Todd A. Pletcher v New York State Gaming Commission Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided March 12, 2026 Judges Garry, P.J.Reynolds FitzgeraldMcShanPowersMackey Attorneys and Parties Todd A. Pletcher Petitioner Attorneys: Andrew J. Mollica New York State Gaming Commission Respondent Attorneys: Letitia James, Jonathan D. Hitsous Brief Summary Issue Thoroughbred racing medication…
Matter of Abigail X. February 27, 2026
Matter of Abigail X. Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided February 26, 2026 Judges GarryCeresiaFisherMcShanMackey Attorneys and Parties Abigail X. Petitioner-Appellant Attorneys: M. Lettie Dickerson New York City Anti-Violence Project and another Amici Curiae Attorneys: Evan M. Gilbert Brief Summary Issue Sealing of name-change records for a transgender petitioner under New York Civil…
Federal National Mortgage Association v. Marshall February 23, 2026
Federal National Mortgage Association v. Marshall Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided February 19, 2026 Judges Reynolds Fitzgerald, J.P.CeresiaFisherMcShanMackey Attorneys and Parties Lawrence C. Marshall Defendant-Appellant Attorneys: Marlene Morales Melo Federal National Mortgage Association Plaintiff-Respondent Attorneys: Adam M. Swanson Brief Summary Issue Mortgage foreclosure; whether the Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act (FAPA) bars lenders…
Matter of Alex Y. v Mindy X. February 2, 2026
Matter of Alex Y. v Mindy X. Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided January 29, 2026 Judges Pritzker, J.P.FisherMcShanPowersMackey Attorneys and Parties Appellant — Mindy X. Attorneys: Lora J. Tryon Respondent — Alex Y. Attorneys: Laurie L. Paro Attorney for the Child Attorneys: Amanda P. Geary Brief Summary Issue Child custody modification under…
Lucas Smith et al. v. Nche Zama et al. January 5, 2026
Lucas Smith et al. v. Nche Zama et al. Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided December 31, 2025 Judges PritzkerFisherMcShanPowersMackey Attorneys and Parties Lucas Smith et al. Plaintiffs-Appellants Attorneys: Charles L. Falgiatano Nche Zama Defendant-Respondent Attorneys: Karen G. Felter Arnot Ogden Medical Center; Arnot Health Inc.; Arnot Medical Services, PLLC Defendants-Respondents Attorneys: Tomas…
Matter of Martin Baher v. Anthony Rodriguez December 19, 2025
Matter of Martin Baher v. Anthony Rodriguez Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided December 18, 2025 Judges Clark, J.P.AaronsLynchCeresiaMcShan Attorneys and Parties Martin Baher Petitioner Attorneys: pro se Anthony Rodriguez, as Acting Director of Special Housing and Inmate Disciplinary Programs Respondent Attorneys: Letitia James, Kate H. Nepveu Brief Summary Issue Corrections and prison…
Matter of the Claim of Grace Panday December 19, 2025
Matter of the Claim of Grace Panday Reversed Court Appellate Division, Third Department Date Decided December 18, 2025 Judges Garry, P.J.AaronsReynolds FitzgeraldMcShanMackey Attorneys and Parties RLRG & Associates LLC Appellant Attorneys: Keith O'Donnell Grace Panday Respondent Attorneys: David E. Woodin Commissioner of Labor Respondent Brief Summary Issue Unemployment insurance (UI) eligibility where a claimant declines…